The NY Times recently had an article exploring what the appropriate age is to leave children home alone. Anyone who is a parent has faced this dilemma and I can honestly say that it is the number one thing I have conversations about with other parents of tweens. Hushed conversations, because this topic is so divisive. One friend wouldn’t leave her child home alone until he was 14, while yet another friend allows her 8 yr old to arrive home to an empty house every afternoon for a couple hours until she gets home from work. Both feel as though the other is judging their decision.
As for me I sort of shrug. Both seem slightly extreme to me, but who am I to judge each individual circumstance?
I spent every afternoon home alone when I was a child from the time I was in third grade. And by the time I was in seventh grade I spent my summers and school breaks home alone. I lived on the beach and was allowed to go there everyday. Something I am certain I would not feel comfortable allowing my 13 yr old to do.
As far as my children staying home alone, or babysitting siblings, I have broken them in slowly. Leaving them for short periods of time and gradually increasing the time. I have also discovered that personalities play a huge role rather than strictly age. My oldest son rules the house in absence with an iron fist. He is the rule enforcer. There will be no fun under his watch. I am exaggerating of course, but when I return home after leaving him in charge the house is tidy, everyone is quietly doing something like watching tv, and any snacks or food that were eaten were explicitly served by him.
My next oldest son, who is just one year younger, is all about having fun. He is the one who will think nothing of baking brownies or cupcakes with his siblings to entertain them. And leave every single baking utensil I own laying out in the kitchen. There will have been elaborate games played and toys will be everywhere.
Both of them are great with their siblings, but they do so very differently. And both of their styles are okay. I was slightly more worried about my younger son but then one day we had a kitchen fire while I was home and cooking and he was the one who ran for the fire extinguisher and put the fire out.
I have to wonder if the economy has caused parents to leave their children, who are right on the cusp of their comfort zone, home alone because they can not afford a babysitter or summer camp.
On the NYT parenting blog, Motherlode, Lisa Belkin asks, “At what age would you let your child…?”
She then poses a list of questions to ponder.
Among them,
stay in the car while you run an errand?
go on a date?
see a PG-13 movie?
babysit for the neighbor’s children?
How do you feel about this? Do you have any hardfast rules about what ages your children need to be before they can do certain things or have certain privileges? Did you have any hardfast rules that you reconsidered? And if so, why did you reconsider?